I watched President Obama deliver The State of The Union last night, and our our president gives good speech. However, there was one part that anyone following me on twitter saw had me a little caught up.
Okay, a lot caught up.
President Obama proposes that every state make it law that youth cannot leave high school until they either graduate or turn 18. No more high school drop outs. Sounds good in theory doesn’t it? Well no, not to me it doesn’t and I’m a certified school social worker.
SocialJerk (@SocialJerkBlog) made the excellent point that, “Truancy is a MUCH more complicated problem than ‘harsher law!’”
I work with youth at risk, with homeless youth, and with youth aging out of the foster care system (aka soon to be homeless) a lot of my participants are the ones counting down til their 16th birthday so they can officially drop out, but not always for the reasons you’d assume.
Being warehoused in a a high school until 16 or the new proposed 18 isn’t always in the child’s best interest. If the youth has other barriers to contend with, other priorities like finding safe warm places to sleep at night and food to eat no amount of you must attend school until X age is going to compel them to do so.
But currently at 16 they can get a signed release from their school or district and take the GED. This makes them more employable than they’d be as “just another street youth drop out”. Why would we put another two years between them and that opportunity? I also help a number of my participants who get their GEDs go on to post secondary.
High schools are a kind of hell for some kids for so many reasons and that’s not being addressed by just requiring them to be there. Maybe I’m a cynic (okay, no maybe about it) but what I see is more kids on the BECCA bill being fined for non-attendance, because they still won’t go to school. They can’t pay those fines, their parents won’t pay those fines and the youth will start their adulthood in debt. They’ll finally be able to get their GED at 18…if they’re still motivated to do so. If they haven’t found a more lucrative and fun way to pass their time among their new street friends. Because raising the age of attendance to 18 or 21 or 45 isn’t going to make my clients go to high school if they already aren’t going.
I still love you Mr. President, but it’s a really bad idea. Don’t worry though SJ and I will be your new sassy and witty social work advisors. We’ve got this.






